DID YOU KNOW? All garage door technicians are employees of Overhead Door Company. We never use subcontractors.

DID YOU KNOW? All garage door technicians are employees of Overhead Door Company. We never use subcontractors.

Do I Need to Repair or Replace My Garage Door?

Across the nation, the garage door has become the front door, often serving as the primary entry point for many households. The average American family opens and closes their garage door approximately 1,500 times annually, as they hustle in and out for various engagements. Such regular usage may result in cracked panels, chipped paint, and worn-out components.

Addressing a damaged garage door promptly is vital. Neglecting minor issues can worsen over time, potentially inviting pests and security risks. A damaged door can also increase heating or cooling costs due to air leaks. Additionally, it can significantly impact your home’s curb appeal.

The decision comes down to repair or replace. We’ll outline when each option is suitable, and offer guidance on enhancing your home’s appearance, safety, and functionality.

Repair or Replace — Narrowing the Decision

What is the average lifespan of a garage door? Typically, a garage door can last between 20 and 30 years with regular upkeep. However, longevity can vary based on several circumstances. For instance, a garage door in a coastal area is prone to quicker deterioration due to exposure to saltwater, while one under constant sunlight will age faster than a shaded counterpart. Wooden doors possess their distinct characteristics. In cases where the driveway slope allows for standing water, the bottom section is likely to deteriorate more rapidly.

So, when is it time to replace or repair your garage door? The decision depends on various factors.

1. Types of Garage Door Damage

Your garage door may have suffered minor cosmetic issues or significant functional flaws:

  • Minor: Superficial damage that doesn’t affect the door’s structure or operation, like chipped paint or minor cracks, is repairable and more cost-effective than replacement.
  • Moderate: Damage that compromises both the appearance and structural integrity, such as warping or rusting, warrants a replacement for optimal functionality and security.
  • Serious: When the damage significantly hinders the door’s operation, like not opening or closing smoothly, a new door is necessary. Ensure to troubleshoot potential simple issues before opting for a replacement, like checking batteries or springs.

2. The Extent of the Damage

If your door has only minor issues, like peeling paint, a repair job is likely the way to go. It could be as simple as a fresh new paint job! However, if it’s dealing with cracked panels, screeching noises, and jerky operation, it might be time for an upgrade. If the door poses a security risk to your home, getting a new, sturdy replacement is pivotal for ensuring protection for your family and home.

3. Cost

When choosing between repairing or replacing your garage door, expenses play a crucial role. Opting to replace a faulty spring on an otherwise functional door is a logical decision, rather than replacing the entire door. If you find yourself needing to replace more than one section or panel, it’s usually more beneficial to opt for a complete door replacement. Despite the similar costs, a full replacement provides you with brand-new hardware (such as hinges, tracks, and springs) and, most importantly, a fresh warranty for the entire system. Explore cost-effective options that offer both style and affordability.

4. The Age of the Door

If your garage door shows minor damage, but has aged significantly — perhaps between 10 and 20 years old — it might be time to think about getting a new one. An older door typically requires replacement sooner rather than later, making repairs a questionable investment for a door reaching the end of its lifespan. Upgrading to a new door, even if the damage isn’t severe enough to mandate it, can bring additional perks like a refreshed look or a better match with your home’s style.

Overhead Door Residential Garage Doors

Overhead Door offers a wide selection of residential garage doors, perfect for upgrading your outdated model. If you need guidance on initiating the replacement process, the Mid-Atlantic Door Group team is ready to assist you. Reach out to one of our eight locations across the region to get started today.

About The Author | Justin White


Justin White is the VP of Marketing for Mid-Atlantic Door Group, Inc. The company opened in 1973 and now consists of (3) official Overhead Door™ Distributors and (8) warehouse locations throughout Maryland, DC, Virginia and Pennsylvania. Justin was born into the door industry, ultimately following in his father's footsteps and joining the family owned business in 2011. After spending time in the field with fellow mechanics, Justin found his niche in marketing, along with a specialty in residential garage door sales, installation, and service.

Garage Door Services

Since 1973, Mid-Atlantic Door Group, Inc. has been providing Washington DCFrederick MD, Southern MD, Northern VA, Fredericksburg VA, Richmond VA, Harrisburg PA, Hanover PA, and the surrounding areas with the most reliable and trusted garage door services. These services include new door sales, professional installation, and 24/7 garage door repair services on all makes and models.

We are the region's only Authorized Overhead Door™ Distributors. All of our products enjoy the garage door industry's best warranty.

Explore the interactive map below to see the areas and locations that we proudly serve.